Podcast 60Revision #2, 7/2/2009 1:34 AM
Podcast 60Revision #3, 7/2/2009 7:40 AM
18.104.22.168: "Initial edit to 2:58"
Spolsky: edit me!
Atwood: edit me!
Atwood: One of the rules of StackOverflow is a little bit Fight Club like in that
we don't, we prefer that people don't discuss StackOverflow on StackOverflow.
Spolsky: You can tell by the meta site exactly why we prefer that.
Atwood: Well, really you think that's true ? I actually had one user comment on Twitter ?.com added "Man I really fought you on this meta thing and now that you've opened Pandora's Box I see what you were talking about". Why do you say that then Joel ?
Spolsky: Well the reason I don't like having meta on any discussion group is that it's something for, well, a lot of it is something for newbies right like. The first thing that happens is a newbie comes into the discussion group and starts hanging out and like "Wow this is really fun, I like this discussion group".
Atwood: But they have all kinds of feature requests and ideas and stuff like that and the first thing they want to do is start reorganising it in their image. You know...
Atwood: Really ?
Spolsky: You know they start discussing like "Why can't you sort the things here by color ?" and whatever maybe.
Spolsky: And now because they're newbies they're noticing the same thing that all the other newbies noticed and brought up as subjects of conversation and because they're newbies they don't know that these things have been talked about endlessly. And they're boring to the people that actually live in the newsgroup and use it, for news...
Atwood: I see.
Spolsky: And discussion or whatever.
Atwood: Well isn't that the point in which you, the grizzled veteran, would point to the fact.
Atwood: And force the user to go...
Spolsky: Read the fricking FAQ.
Atwood: I have noticed that, and actually that's something that came up on UserVoice a lot was that you would get the same stuff over and over and over.